Thursday, August 25, 2016

Hitler, Trump, Hillary and Social Network Data

Last night on Facebook I saw an interesting post from someone I went to school with... here's the general nature of his complaint: 
He's fairly conservative (a Trump supporter) and recently created a post on Facebook that likened Hillary Clinton to Hitler.  One of his friends reported the post to Facebook, and Facebook removed the post from visibility, labeling it offensive.
This post actually struck me fairly hard. Two reasons:
  1. I may not agree that Hillary is effectively Adolf Hitler, but it seems firmly within this guy's rights to compare political candidates to Hitler. In fact, there's nothing really more American than comparing people you disagree with to Nazis (there's even a social-science internet law about this).
  2. I see people compare Donald Trump to Hitler all the time. Literally... all the time, with no apparent repercussions. Is there a double standard on Facebook in comparing Hillary to Hitler? This is especially interesting to me considering Facebook's reported bias against conservatives (which they blamed on rogue employees).
So, I thought it might be interesting to dig into the data of Hitler references on contemporary social media, and see what people most often discuss in relation to Hitler. Here's what I found on Twitter:
  1. The most common term, by far, used when discussing Hitler is "Trump."
  2. Right now, there are only really two Hitler related topical discussions on Twitter: one related to Trump and the other pertaining to Syria.


I downloaded the last ten days of tweets (all tweets) containing the hashtag "#Hitler," which was around 15K total tweets. I ran a cleanup algorithm I designed to remove tweets that contain duplicate content, likely tweetbot posts, and spam. The result was about 3,500 clean tweets that mentioned Hitler and were unlikely to be spam.  

Then I conducted some text-data cleaning steps, you can look at some prior posts on this site to understand what this entails, but generally it removes frequent words that are less meaningful (e.g. "the") and reduces words to their stem, or root meaning (e.g. "run" and "running" are interpreted the same way).  


I wanted to solve two questions with this analysis:

  1. What do people talk about most when they say Hitler on social media (sub-question: how often is Trump mentioned?)
  2. What are the general topics of conversation regarding Hitler?

The first part of the analysis was easy, and I found that Tweets with the term "Hitler" most often use the word "Trump" followed by a series of words related to elections including "like" and "support." Terms related to nazis are also popular, specifically, "adolf" and "nazi."

Of note, "Hillary" or "Clinton" aren't in the top 20 terms associated with Hitler, though Trump's Twitter user name is, as well as marginally associated words "never" (as in never Trump) and "vote." Searching the data, Hillary was mentioned about 90 times in the data set, so Hitler tweets are only about 12% as likely to contain Hillary as they are to contain Trump.

And here's what those tweets look like as a wordcloud.:

Next, I wanted to discover the underlying topics inside the data, for which I used correlated topic models (CTMs). I've written about them before on this blog, and technical specifications can be found here. For this analysis, I reduced my dataset to just tweets that hash-tagged "Hitler," for two reasons: 
  • faster processing
  • only analyze tweets with the strongest relation to Hitler
The algorithm seemed to converge on only two detected topics. What does that mean? Over the past week, people on Twitter mentioning Hitler have generally been talking about one of two things 1. Trump and 2. Assad of Syria. Here's the top terms by these two topics:

One might argue that Trump supporters are also mentioning Hitler, but the term output makes it more clear who is invoking Hitler and Trump.  It is generally the "Never" Trump movement as evidenced by the terms "Never" and "Trump The Fraud." For a bit more color, here are the associated wordclouds from each topic.

First Assad:

And now Trump (my favorite random association is "Vote Hitler"):

For some final color on this, here is an example of a couple of Tweets, generally representative of the Trump category:


A few takeaways:
  • The most common topic discussed on Twitter when using the term Hitler is "Trump." Users seem to continuously make the comparison of Trump to Hitler, without being punished by the social media platform.
  • The main two subjects of discussion when talking about Hitler on Twitter appears to be Trump and Assad. This isn't hugely surprising about Assad given recent news out of the middle east. The Trump comparisons to Hitler, is a bit more jarring, given that he is the Presidential candidate for a major US party.
QUICK COMMENTARY: The guy with the banned post from the beginning of this entry just posted that he challenged the banned post with Facebook, and Facebook gave in and said that it was in fact appropriate. This is interesting, and it tends to coincide with previous articles stating that individuals at Facebook who receive front line complaints are often biased against conservative views, and tend to over-extend censorship towards conservative positions. Obviously, I looked at a different social network, but it is commonplace to compare Trump to Hitler, so it seems like the Hillary to Hitler comparison shouldn't be censored. 


  1. If your an internet marketer, affiliate marketer, entrepreneur or just someone who wants to use internet marketing on social networks, there are a few tactics and strategies you'll need to consider before going after your intended target market. Social Marketing

  2. Examine the concept of grit in effective leaders. Business are faltering, surrounded by ongoing global threats. Many organizations become conservative and fearful when faced with uncertainty and high risk. The characteristic of grit can help leaders overcome the challenges of this chaotic business climate. Read More

  3. Over 10 years ago huge online companies like the mighty Microsoft with MSN, then Yahoo! and even the newly rising industry giant Google all saw a rising need for social networking websites. They knew that the wave of the future was in the growing popularity of social networks.

  4. Hi Levi,
    Thanks a lot for this amazing article !
    Another good idea is to add your Twitter Handle to an RSVP linky list if one is provided in the party announcement post. RSVP’ing is often optional, but a great way to get people – including the party host – to follow you.

  5. The main component of a flourishing business is the efficiency of marketing efforts. Marketing elements are usually trustworthy, but with the change in technology and consumer's tastes and lifestyle, it directly affects the business. Search Engine Optimization

  6. Search engine marketing (SEM) is likewise structure on web advertising like online networking promoting, email promoting, versatile publicizing and presentation promoting.SEO near you

  7. business is the efficiency of marketing efforts.

  8. I Will Provide SEO Blog Comment Service. & niche relevant blog comment service we provide a quality service with 100% Buyer satisfaction and My team Believed in Quality work not Quantity Contact me Now 24/7.check out this Blog for your business . your business will be gain 200% more profit I can not recommend you guys enough. seo service

  9. Thanks for sharing this post. Hope you have a great weekend ahead.
    WPengine Coupon
    Siteground Coupon

  10. I am additionally going to guide per users of the post on the most proficient method to expand space power effortlessly by applying my tips in up and coming post. accounting firm seo

  11. Internet marketing is very important for online business and making your credible identity. It affects online reputation for your business too. Giving right company to perform seo for your business is very important. Many seo companies provide customised seo packages depending upon need of business firm. Search Engine Optimization Freelancers

  12. One of the best things about Craigslist is that it is one of the best sites to post multiple ads with minimal cost spent on internet marketing. However, if you are a business owner with a large inventory to keep track of, the process can become overwhelmingly difficult to manage. CRAIGSLIST POSTING SERVICE

  13. If you want to find out how to have prospects banging down your door asking about you and your business opportunity then I recommend getting a copy of the course Magnetic Sponsoring. This is the best course in the industry that teaches attraction marketing techniques.
    Social Network

  14. If you’re looking for excellent Workers.We are here to provide Internet Marketing services and help people. We offer NICHE Relevant Manual Blog Comment Service , We can rank you for any keyword on Google I will be very happy to offer my service to you. Please feel free to message me and talk about any queries

  15. In order to cater some needs of users, the R&D team did many researches and had successfully added a new function for this desktop app that allows users to follow soundcloud plays user realizing checking updates of single soundcloud plays user which brought good news to soundcloud plays music listeners and appreciators.

  16. We found that ultimately they are losing the value of the site. So they decided to make all backlinks from their site as nofollow so that backlink benefit will not be shared back to other pages. This way they are not losing out any link juice to any other pages. Dofollow Backlink

  17. Hello, I will Provied SEO Niche Blog Comment Service . All comment relevant with your blog. I know every tips of niche blog comment . This service bring you lots of traffic . We Just say the post be real. That showing your personality is much more important than showing off your knowledge in the niche.

  18. A search engine optimization service looks at your website, and then makes some decisions. The first decision is how to describe your website so that it draws some attention. fl search engine optimization agency

  19. Business activity may be connected with production of goods or services. Now that you've got your products all imported, it's time to set up your fulfillment section. The business is selling its items to an individual. Hosted storefronts are an easy way to set-up your own Web store and a good option for small or individual sellers who aren't quite ready to invest in a large ecommerce website. When the business is small having an online website would advertise your store as well as the products you are selling. Apttus E-Commerce with artificial intelligence provides actionable insights to your business. Get a holistic and detailed view of your business to better understand sales, orders, and audience to better tailor your products and marketing. When evaluating these options , consider how well suited they are to the type and volume of products you sell.


  20. The company sells a variety of dog collars on their online store. This can be done by promoting it everyday on the radio so that people can know about e-commerce and how it works. 3. E-commerce essentially involves monetary trade while in e-business, money transactions are not necessary. Connect to Customers with 360° support for digital marketing and marketplace expansion on channels like Amazon, eBay, Walmart, Google, Facebook and dozens of others. 4. If the customers select the buy button then another screen of shopping cart will be opened. This demands an entirely different software that's simpler and accommodating for sending links to customers with the digital content downloads. If you want to sell document downloads, I'd definitely choose Shopify here as Wix only caters to music downloads when it comes to digital

  21. Showcasing on the web has taken some emotional directional changes in the course of the last couple of years.Due to the developing notoriety of online social locales, promoting and marking your business has turned out to be more improved and less demanding to do.Read on to find the 3 key parts each social advertising methodology must need to take full favorable position this colossal popularity.Click Here


  22. If you are running a physical store, it will be limited by the geographical area that you can service, but with an e-Commerce website, you can sell your products and services across the world. It's mainly about installing a bit of code, so you shouldn't have problems with most content management systems or ecommerce platforms. In C2C e-commerce, individuals sell to other individuals. Take your web sales beyond the ordinary with interactive online store, composing the ability for both public and wholesale ordering, secure payment gateways, ERP integration and multiple order methods available. KartRocket's DIY eCommerce solution enables you to easily create an online store, design & customize it in less than 10 min. This can make it more expensive than selling through your own online site, especially if you're working with more expensive items.


  23. Allows quick delivery of products and services in some cases, especially with digitized products. Finally, if you sell software or digital products like ebooks, share-it! Name the website relevant to the products you are selling, so it would be easy for people to find it. E-commerce is a relatively new concept in India and as such various aspects related to it are still developing. You must need consistent follow up system and have a blueprint on how you can grow your ecommerce business further. This storefront application adds a customizable shopping tab to your Facebook Business Page. With eCommerce combined, all your sales channels are in one POS system. Shopify integrates with apps like Ordoro, Inventory Source, and eCommHub, making it easy to set up your dropshipping business.

    The disadvantages of promoting e-commerce on a newspaper is it wont get some peoples attention about the company. All these mentioned points are the backbone of any product selling website, without which no ecommerce business would survive. Our in-house web development team can provide you with a great new website allowing you to easily sell your products on the internet. ATG Stores launches to sell decorative items for the home online. You can even survey your customers upon purchase of your online digital product or ask them to subscribe to your newsletter. Appearance is everything, in order to secure the confidence of your online customers you ecommerce website will need to give your customers reassurance of legitimate business and branding along with a professional layout and design to make all aspects of the online shop as transparent as

  24. Marketing products through the internet, or simply known as internet marketing, enables a company anywhere in the world to reach the global market and receive instant feedback. top website designing company

  25. If you have taken a course in programming, have work experience as a server manager, or if you are naturally technically minded and self taught, then this branch of SEO expertise is for you. dennis seo profile

  26. Hi definitely there, yes this paragraph is in fact definitely beneficial and also I invite reality found deal of elements from it fretting blog website developing. many thanks.

  27. Herpes is one of the prettiest disgusting diseases that can result in a plethora of conditions like ulcers all over the body, cold sores, etc. In addition to pain, this type of condition also results in creating embarrassment in the public.

  28. The Dating Apocalypse Secrets

  29. Very nice post. It is very interesting and informative. Thank you for the sharing. We are providing Professional Craigslist Posting Service

  30. Social media is making a huge impact in our daily life nowadays and so on the marketing industry. Digital marketing has become most of social media oriented nowadays. digital agency canada

  31. meditation in a bottle review

    welcome the health benefits that come from being in and Alpha State. And the great thing about Meditation In A Bottle is that

    it really is suitable for everyone. After all, there’s no point in anyone’s life when you stop worrying about your well-

    being. So why wouldn’t you take a daily supplement that truly has a positive effect on yours


  32. Nutrition Hacks Joint Pain Hack Review

    The Joint Pain Hack supplement works in three phases. The first phase aims to relieve pain and inflammation. In the second

    phase, it fixes your cartilage (the slightly firm, flexible, and white tissue that connects bones together). The third phase

    will rehydrate your joints.How will this supplement hydrate your joints? It contains an ingredient called “Agent Orange” and

    hyaluronic acid.


  33. Joint Pain Hack Review

    A joint ache is one of the worse ways to limit oneself to bed. Not only is the pain excruciatingly challenging to tolerate but

    it also affects one’s mobility. Top this up with the internal swelling in the joint region and declined flexibility, and one

    becomes good for nothing. Dependence on others increases. Simultaneously, both work and personal life suffer. Most of the over

    the counter solutions are only superficially useful. They make big claims but show no valuable results.

  34. Nutrition Hacks Fungus Hack

    The Nutrition Hacks Fungus Hack is a supplement highly dedicated in curing toenail fungus. Its natural compositions and

    antioxidant properties help into weakening the compounds responsible for developing the disease, moreover replacing them with

    natural enzymes that regain toenail health.


  35. Nutrition Hacks Fungus Download

    The Nutrition Hacks Fungus Hack supplement is developed by Brett Johnson, a health laboratory specialist. Through his

    expertise and dedicated supervision to his team, he turned natural ingredients that are commonly found in local markets into a

    pill. Thus, the Nutrition Hacks Fungus Hack was born.

  36. Nutrition Hacks Fungus PDF

    The main benefit of using Nutrition Hacks Fungus Hack is curing toenail fungus and overall wellness of the body against

    parasitic fungus infection. Preventive benefits are present when taking the supplement from potential infections such as

    internal fungal infection, eczema, and other related infections.


  37. Fungus Hack Reviews

    Fungus Hack Reviews essentially in light of the fact that for a substantial piece of the year, the vast majority of us have

    socks and shoes on, which are perfect for developing growth since Fungus Hack free trial they are dim and normally soggy to a

    specific degree. Our toenails and fingernails are quite compelling obstructions against harm and contamination.

  38. Barbarian xl review

    Increase the size of your such as that of security, is not your main concern when trying to do anything. You walk around with

    the Barbarian XL System weight at the end of your penis when you get stretch marks, as well as appealing woman can never warp.

    In this position, you should not take your enlargement pills to prevent pregnancy induce, most of them do not lead to the

    results you expect and the fact they can lead to unwanted side effects.

  39. Zenith vision 20 tablet review

    The Vision 20 requires regular use and is suitable for both males and females. When taken properly, it may be expected that

    both day and night vision would clear considerably. Adults usually need to be able to read small text like medicine labels,

    recipes, newspapers, etc, and so this could be quite a blessing!


  40. Zenith vision 20 pills review

    If a supplement has Zenith Labs behind it, it is quite a heartening fact for those who are looking for an alternative to

    conventional synthetic medicine. The Vision 20 supplement and many others are usually backed up by the guarantee of this name.

    We may thus proceed with more confidence in ordering the Vision 20 for the sake of our eye health.


  41. Zenith labs vision 20 review

    If we have healthy eyes but are experiencing difficulties in certain vision activities, we really should consider the Vision

    20 for enhancing our eye health. This could greatly help us see better when using screen, reading, or driving at any time of

    the day or night. Since certain activities, especially driving, could be extremely dangerous if we can’t see properly, it’s

    high time to act instead of battling the symptoms on your own.


  42. Digital marketing has taken the key role of the marketing sector nowadays. SEO services have become the key role player for that reason. Organic SEO Services

  43. The panalean review

    Losing weight and burning fat from stubborn parts of your body is not easy for everyone because recently I noticed that people

    are showing their interest on eating junk foods, processed foods, deep fried oil foods, sweeten confectioneries and other

    dense foods. And they are feeling bored and tired to do their daily activity by sitting in front of the computer to waste

    their time and life on doing useless things.

  44. BioLeptin review

    BioLeptin is a revolutionary dietary supplement, which is well formulated with scientifically proven ingredients to boost your

    fat burning metabolism. It has a blend of chromium and African Mango IGOB131 to reprogram the hypothalamus in your brain, it

    resets biological set point and reverses leptin resistance for maximizing the weight loss process as faster.

  45. BioLeptin Tips

    BioLeptin will help your brain to regulate the function of the hypothalamus and also reverse the leptin resistance in your

    body to take control of your weight gain as well as weight loss by resetting your biological setpoint. You will get benefit

    from African Mango which acts as a mighty weight loss miracle because the extraction IGOB131 works effectively by combining

    with other essential minerals to take control of craving, boosting metabolism, enhancing mood and gain more energy.

  46. BioLeptin Supplement reviews

    BioLeptin will remove the extra ugly fat from your body. So, you will not suffer from low energy. This supplement helps us to

    feel best about our body in just three weeks. Adam Glass has included all the natural and pure quality ingredients in this

    supplement. It will ensure us we never get any side effects on the body. The original effectiveness of Irvingia Gabonensis

    makes us gain all the positive outcome on our body. It helps us to manage the long-term disease, and avoid the cause of weight


  47. How To Buy A Parallel Profits On A Shoestring Budget -

  48. Normal blood sugar levels are less than 100 mg/dL after not eating (fasting) for at least eight hours. And they're less than 140 mg/dL two hours after eating. During the day, levels tend to be at their lowest just before meals.

  49. Blood sugar, or glucose, is the main sugar found in blood. The body gets glucose from the food we eat. This sugar is an important source of energy and provides nutrients to the body's organs, muscles and nervous system. The absorption, storage and production of glucose is regulated constantly by complex processes involving the small intestine, liver and pancreas.

  50. We are here to give you a complete review on the Parallel Profit project by Steve Clayton and Aidan Booth. If you are someone from the field you would already be familiar with these two names, for those of who are new. Parallel Profits Review

  51. Pure Green Cold Pressed Juice is a juicing brand developed for those with hectic and tiring lifestyles. The brand’s products help you to get through your day feeling alert, refreshed, awake, and rejuvenated.

  52. Think Your Marketing Strategy Is Safe? 9 Ways You Can Lose It Today -

  53. Keto 900 – Keto and is that the best weight loss supplement that's devised to form you the slimmer and slender one while not harming your body. This supplement I created by combining the natural botanicals in its formation. Its consistent consumption can lead you to lower your weight while not taking the other aiding approaches like strict meals, harsh workouts, completely different supplements intake.

  54. Adtrics Academy On A Budget: 5 Tips From The Great Depression -

  55. I have recently been recently facing candidiasis problem with my differing of the physical body like Vaginal, Toungue and Epidermis from last 5 years. I got This site & got rest from it. See here my full tale:

  56. 9 Ways You Can Reinvent Forex Duality Without Looking Like An Amateur -

  57. Failures Make You Nd10x Review Better Only If You Understand These 6 Things

  58. Thanks for every other informative site. The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such an ideal means? I have a venture that I’m just now operating on, and I have been on the look out for such information. niche relevant manual blog comment service

  59. You know your projects stand out of the herd. There is something special about them. It seems to me all of them are really brilliant! niche relevant manual blog comment service